She's neither living, nor dead. She's a spirit. Her name is Samantha.
"It's really creepy," said the Inn's owner Garrett McCarthy.
When McCarthy purchased the bar back in 1994, he already knew the 'spooky' stories. The folks who originally owned the place at the turn of the 20th century had always claimed it was haunted.
"You've got to figure something this old has something to say," McCarthy said. "If the walls could talk!"
McCarthy says he's heard weird noises, even seen bizarre things out of the corner of his eye.
"I would say a day doesn't go by where I don't see something out of the corner of my eye," McCarthy said.
But what a customer captured on camera two weeks ago was something McCarthy never expected to see.
"I couldn't believe it," he said.
An image showing two patrons sitting at the bar was interrupted by a blurry orange head over one of the patron's shoulders.
"There's an orange misty glow," McCarthy said. "We're debating whether it's a boy or a girl."
Some say it's Samantha, others say it's nothing.
Whatever it is, it's causing a stir in Louisville.
What do you think it is?